DC's "New 52" Rankings - The Second Half

Here are my rankings of DC's "New 52" books at the end of the relaunch's second half. I'll be using the following key:


All In - I'm hooked indefinitely. Or at least until they change the creative team.

Probation - This book's good enough to buy through the first story arc, based on this issue, but not good enough to give it an "All In". Yet.

Double Secret Probation - This book didn't do it for me overall, but there's just enough going for it (i.e. strong art or a writer with a great past history) to give it one or maybe two more issues before dumping it.

Drop It Like It's Hot - This book is now dead to me. You couldn't get me to buy this at gunpoint.

Look Closer - I may not have given this book a fair shot. I'll check it out again next week. Maybe.


Here are my rankings of the comics that have come out so far:


Aquaman#1 - This book had a lot going for it. Ivan Reis and Joe Prado illustrated the hell out of this one, just as they always do. And there were some great character moments, especially the brief part when Aquaman is reminiscing about his dad taking him to the same diner when he was a kid. Overall this book was very good. But for it to get better Geoff Johns is going to have to overcome some of his bad tendencies. The first is his tendency towards blood and gore, as seen in a restrained-by-Johns-standards scene with The Trench at the end of the issue. The second is his "Aquaman IS Cool, Dammit!" fixation. Johns loaded this first issue with nearly every type of Aquaman joke he could think of. The "Aquaman is a joke" trope was taken to ridiculous degrees here, particularly in the scenes where the local policemen use it 30 seconds after Aquaman singlehandedly flipped an armored truck over his head using only his trident and then leaped away from rooftop to rooftop Hulk-style. Once again, with the exception of Jim Gordon, Maggie Sawyer, Harvey Bullock, Renee Montoya, and the cops in Animal Man#1, the police in the New 52 are as dumb as a bag of hammers. If Johns gets these tendencies out of his system, this book could move its way to "All In", but for now, it's....
Probation


All Star Western#1 - Jonah Hex done Vertigo-style in a Gotham City setting with hints of Ruse and The Kents thrown in. What's not to love? Not sure how long this can be sustained as an ongoing, but I'm perfectly content to enjoy the ride in the meantime.
All In


Batman#1 - I was literally the last man to jump aboard the Scott Snyder bandwagon, but the James Gordon Jr. arc in Detective was enough to get me to buy this. Here, Snyder delivers a great jumping-on point. But Greg Capullo puts it over the top. The only thing by Capullo I'd seen this century was Disturbed's "Land Of Confusion" video, but, except for the design of the Bat-Villains in the opening scene, I enjoyed his work, particularly his depiction of the title character, who looked like a cross between the versions of Bats depicted in Dave Mazzuchelli's Year One, Frank Miller's Dark Knight Returns#1, and frequent Capullo collaborator Todd McFarlane's Year Two. The only other tiny complaint I had with Capullo's art was in an NSFW tweet here.
All In


Batman: The Dark Knight#1 - If you can only buy ONE New 52 Batman series....DON'T make it this one! DC apparently has successfully separated the conjoined Good Paul Jenkins and Bad Paul Jenkins twins, and they assigned Bad Paul to co-write this book. This even made Tony Daniel's wretched Detective#1 look almost good by comparison.
Drop It Like It's Hot


Birds Of Prey#1 - The toughest part of reading this comic was pretending the last nearly 16 years of my comic-reading life never happened. I miss Gail, Oracle, Dinah, Helena, and Zinda together like nobody's business. That said, once I divorce myself from the pre-reboot stories, BOP#1 is a strong issue in it's own right, especially the Jesus Saiz art.
Probation


Blackhawks#1 - This was another book that suffered from lack of Zinda, except this one had much less going for it.
Drop It Like It's Hot


Blue Beetle#1 -  I expected this book to be an "All In". It had so many of the pieces: Jaime, the Scarab, Brenda, Mr & Mrs. Reyes, La Dama. But, for the most part, this didn't click. Part of it was that Bedard retold Jaime's origin when the old one was still in perfect condition. The thing I hate most about reboots is having to keep watching the reinvention of the wheel. The problem is that of all the changes made to the backstory, NONE WERE IMPROVEMENTS. Making Paco a dropout gang-banger is a prime example. Making Jaime more sullen to his parents is another. The one change that DID measure up to the last series was the art by Ig Guara and Ruy Jose. Unfortunately, even that bright spot was marred by Pete Pantazis' unfortunate coloring choices. He uses the same dark and muted colors and backgrounds that obstructed Kevin Maguire's art on the Justice League 90's Retroactive  book.
Double Secret Probation
 

Captain Atom#1 - I never picked up either the Charlton Captain Atom or the late 80's series, but based on the books I HAVE seen, I've always liked Captain Atom better in an ensemble cast than as a solo character.
And this book bore that out. Freddie Williams II's art was hard to read here, and Krul's writing didn't sell me.
Drop It Like It's Hot


Catwoman#1 -  I don't always hate Judd Winick's stuff, but in this case I did. Very much. I've been a Bat-Cat shipper since seeing Adam West and Julie Newmar, but never before has it made me want to vomit.
Drop It Like It's Hot .... and then wash your hands very thoroughly.


DC Universe Presents#1 -  Seeing how Sentry: Fallen Sun and that Civil War: Frontline comic with Sally Floyd were two of the worst comics of all time, I had trepidations about Paul Jenkins. But it's Good Paul Jenkins at work here. The thing I liked about this was that this was the first time in a while we got to see Deadman's work in the big picture. Better yet, Bernard Chang has really stepped up his game this year, and this issue continued that upswing.
Probation


The Flash#1 - Before this book came out, this book had more strikes against it in my eyes than nearly any New 52 title. I think that Wally is vastly superior as a character to Barry and has a vastly superior supporting cast (Linda, Jai, Irey, Chunk, Wally's mom), and I HATE the exile of him and his family to comics limbo. Worse, one of the only interesting aspects of Barry's character, his marriage to Iris, has been OMD'd away. And Barry's handling in Flashpoint didn't exactly endear me to him. That said, I liked this book better than I thought I would. Manapul's art was a factor, but a bigger one may have been that he and Brian Buccellato seem to get what John Broome, Robert Kanigher, and Cary Bates got and Geoff Johns didn't about writing Barry: That it doesn't matter whether or not you make Barry's character and backstory interesting as long as you make the things happening to him interesting. That's why he fought guys like Abra Kadabra and the Mirror Master. Look at all the stuff Carmine Infantino, Ross Andru, and Irv Novick drew in Barry's stories (not to mention what Greg LaRocque and Scott Kolins drew in Wally's).  The fun of the Silver Age Flash stories was seeing a) what crazy situation Barry got into and b) what crazy-ass super-speed trick he would use to get out of it. Manapul and Buccellato seem to understand the first part, at least.
Probation


The Fury Of Firestorm#1 - Holy crap! I'm still processing how I feel about this one. Clearly the rebootiest of the reboots. Can't accuse Van Sciver, Simone, and especially Cinar of not being creative, that's for sure. Some of the Ronnie-Jason animosity felt forced, and I'm not sure of the whole TWO Firestorms dynamic, but I'm interested enough to see where this goes next.
Probation


Green Lantern Corps#1 -  This book should have been an "All In" as I've been collecting it since before the reboot. I love Guy and John to pieces, and Pasarin's art was nicely detailed. Part of the problem was that it was too detailed in places. Specifically, the gory scenes that bookended the issue. DIAL IT DOWN, DC!!! And that's why I have to downgrade my rating to...
Probation


Green Lantern: New Guardians#1 - Yet another instance of Tony Bedard needlessly retooling a character's origin and making no improvement whatsoever. This time the victim is Kyle Rayner, a character I liked enough to follow through a solo run and on the pre-reboot Green Lantern Corps. Especially aggravating about this issue is that apparently none of the other multi-colored Lanterns seem to recognize Kyle, which flies in the face of the last few years of GL books. Tyler Kirkham's art here wasn't as strong as Pasarin's or Mahnke's in the other GL mags.
Double Secret Probation


I, Vampire#1 - Not sure how I feel about this one. Fialkov and Sorrentino do a decent job here, but I prefer my good guy vampires in the Angel/Spike/Nick Knight vein rather than in the Edward Cullen one. It doesn't help that I'm old enough to remember the old JM Dematteis/ Tom Sutton stories either.
Double Secret Probation


Justice League Dark#1 - My favorite of the Justice League books by far. Any time you can get John Constantine, Zatanna, Madame Xanadu, and Rac Shade on the same team...
All In


Legion Of Super-Heroes#1 -  NOW they don't want to reboot the Legion??? Best thing I can figure is that part of the deal of Paul Levitz' departure as DC's CEO must have included some clause giving Levitz complete creative control of the Legion, and he chose to completely blow off the reboot. Bad decision.
Between the dense backstory and this issue's emphasis on less interesting Academy characters like Chemical Kid and Dragonwing, this wasn't the jumping-on point it needed to be.
Drop It Like It's Hot - unless maybe you were reading the book before this issue. (I wasn't.)


Nightwing#1 -    This book hit the ground running.....and swinging....and tumbling....and jumping.  You can see how Eddy Barrows got this gig as soon as you see the first eight pages of the book and the closing fight. The acrobatic scenes just flow and the pacing is lightning-fast. The vllains could stand a little more originality, but a great start overall.
All In


Red Hood And The Outlaws#1 -  I haven't liked Jason Todd since Superboy punched that famous wall, and Arsenal received a full coolectomy after Lian died in Cry For Justice last year. But this book manages to fuck up Starfire beyond recognition as well, turning her from a beautiful and highly emotionally involved alien warrior to an amnesiac emotionally-uninvolved nymphomaniac who doesn't distinguish between her male partners. In other words, a fantasy for douchey guys.
Drop It Like It's Hot.... and then buy some old Wolfman-Perez Titans back issues, some Teen Titans DVD's, and some bottles of tequila. And weep profusely.


The Savage Hawkman - Hate the new Hawkman design. This book was about as accessible as Fort Knox. This did nothing for me, and I loved the Johns/Morales series.
Drop It Like It's Hot


Superman#1 - I've written extensively about my feelings on the Superman reboot, and this comic didn't do a great job of alleviating those concern. Lois remained awesome as usual, even stuck in a producer's role (which I have my reservations about). And Superman, costume aside, wasn't too bad. But Clark was such a mope that I heard the Debbie Downer "MWAH MWAAAHHH" sound effect in my head every time he spoke! And giving Jimmy Olsen a Justin Bieber haircut? WTF??? Also, it seems Perez found a way to conceal the awfulness of the new costume: By drawing most of the figures so small that you can barely make it out. This thing was compressed!! Who's the target audience? Ray Palmer and Henry Pym?
Double Secret Probation - at least until Giffen and Jurgens take over.


Supergirl#1 -  This wasn't as dragged out as Kevin Smith's Bionic Man, but it still was pretty padded. The art was decent, though.
Double Secret Probation


Teen Titans#1 - For every one Greg Capullo who hits a home run with the 1994 Image look, there are several others in this reboot like Brett Booth who demonstrate everything WRONG artistically with that period and style. Lobdell's reworking of Tim as a male Chloe Sullivan, right down to the "Wall Of Weird", is interesting, but perhaps it's the only thing here that is. Anyone notice that two of Lobdell's three books had the exact same ending? I don't just mean "stylistically similar"; I mean THE EXACT SAME ENDING! And as an added bonus we got to see the old Kid Flash costume, one of the best non-Lantern outfits in the history of the DCU, replaced with not one but TWO vastly inferior versions.
Drop It Like It's Hot


Voodoo#1 - DC just released a comic in which almost half the first issue is spent on...A LAP DANCE! Are you fucking KIDDING ME???
Drop It Like It's Hot


Wonder Woman#1 - Azzarello's opener wasn't the most exposition-heavy jumping-on point, and I could have done without the horse decapitation, but this was one of the strongest versions of Diana I've seen in a while. And Cliff Chiang hits it out of the stadium with his art.
All In


And one I rated as "Look Closer" last time:


Omac#1 - How the hell did I manage to only pick this up two weeks after it came out? As Siskoid suggested, I might have been put off by the words "Dan" and "DiDio" on the cover. However, this book was Kirby done proud. It's also Giffen's best work since his first Legion run. Scott Koblish may have been a factor in that. I just hope Omac's human side gets a little more autonomy in the future.
All In